Accounts on the events of 1915 are frequently subject to distortions and errors. In order to dispel these distortions and errors, one must be very careful when choosing words or phrases to describe a specific event or fact.
When giving an account of the events of 1915, the Ottoman government’s decision to move its Armenian subjects away from their residence to other places during World War I is referred to in a number of ways. Examples of this include “relocation”, “exile”, “forced migration”, and “displacement”. Alongside these, one frequently used word is “deportation”. This is, however, an incorrect use of this word, because the meaning of this word does not overlap with the Ottoman government’s decision. In the dispute over whether or not the events of 1915 constituted genocide, individuals situated on both sides of the dispute employ the incorrect use of the word “deportation”. This incorrect use can be attributed to a lack of knowledge about the issue, and more so to inattention or negligence.
It became necessary to write this commentary when the “deportation” word was yet again used incorrectly during the hearing of the Perinçek v. Switzerland case in the Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) on 28 January 2015. Doğu Perinçek’s public rejection to categorize the events of 1915 as genocide during his visit to Switzerland, and whether such a public rejection can be punished or not lays at the heart of this very important case.
When referring to the Ottoman government’s decision to move its Armenian subjects, the applicant Doğu Perinçek (speaking in Turkish) used the phrase “zorla göç”, which was translated by the simultaneous interpreter as “deportation.” Mr. Perinçek’s counsel Mehmet Cengiz (speaking in Turkish) used the word “sürgün”, which was again translated as “deportation”. Perinçek’s other counsel Christian Laurent Pech (speaking in French) used the word “déportation”, which was translated into English as “deportation”. Finally, the counsel for Turkey (a third party to the case), Stefan Talmon (speaking in English) used the word “deportation”.[i] All these cases of the use of the word “deportation” are problematic.
The primary meaning of the word “deportation” in the English language is: “an act or instance of deporting”[ii], the word “deporting” itself meaning “to force (a person who is not a citizen) to leave a country”.[iii] To put it another way, “deportation” means “the removal from a country of an alien whose presence is unlawful or prejudicial”.[iv] As such, “deportation” has no place when describing the Ottoman government’s decision. The Armenian people were subjects of the Ottoman Empire, they were not considered to be aliens. Furthermore, during the war, they were moved within the borders of the Empire, they were not expelled out of the borders.
Mr. Perinçek used the Turkish phrase “zorla göç”, which can be translated as “forced migration”. This is not the same as “deportation”. “Migration” does not necessarily entail moving out of a country,[v] “deportation” does.
Mr. Cengiz used the Turkish word “sürgün”, which can be translated as “banishment” or “exile”.[vi] These too, are not the same as “deportation”. “Banishment” or “exile” do not necessarily entail being forced to move out of a country, “deportation” does.
Mr. Pech’s used the French word “déportation”, which one would assume to be the same as the English word “deportation”. However, these two words do not mean the same thing. The French word “déportation” can either mean “being sent away (as a convict) to a faraway place (specifically to one of the past or present overseas territories of France)”, or “being sent to a concentration camp in another country (during World War II)”.[vii] The French word “déportation” itself poses a complication, since it has very specific historical meanings that cannot be related to the Ottoman government’s decision.
The incorrect use of the English word “deportation” has already been elaborated above, so there is no need to further explain why Mr. Talmon’s use of this word is problematic.
Translation between any two languages is difficult, because each language has its own nuances that may not easily be conveyed in another language. Simultaneous interpretation is even more difficult, as the interpreter is forced continuously translate without a chance to pause and thoroughly evaluate the meaning of words and phrases.
Moving beyond the difficulties of translation, however, it should be reiterated that the English word “deportation” (and also the French word “déportation”) should be avoided in the context of the Ottoman government’s decision. The use of such words leads to misunderstandings about the events of 1915. “Relocation” or “resettlement” are more appropriate words to use in this context. “Relocation” simply means moving or being moved to a different place,[viii] while “resettlement” means “the act or instance of settling or being settled in another place”[ix], and as such both words leave no room for misunderstandings.
[i] The speeches delivered by the mentioned individuals can be accessed on ECHR’s website: http://www.echr.coe.int/Pages/home.aspx?p=hearings&w=2751008_28012015&language=en
[ii] “Deportation”, Merriam-Webster.com, http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/deportation
[iii] “Deport”, Merriam-Webster.com, http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/deporting
[iv] “Deportation”, Merriam-Webster.com.
[v] “Migrate”, Merriam-Webster.com, http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/migration
[vi] Unlike its English translations, the word “sürgün” in Turkish carries no connotations about leaving one’s country. “Banishment” and “exile” do have such connotations, but not entirely. “Sürgün”, Türk Dil Kurumu – Büyük Türkçe Sözlük, http://www.tdk.gov.tr/index.php?option=com_bts&view=bts; “Banish”, Merriam-Webster, http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/banishment; “Exile”, Merriam-Webster, http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/exile.
[vii] “Déportation”, Le-Dictionnaire.com, http://www.le-dictionnaire.com/definition.php?mot=d%E9portation
[viii] “Relocate”, CollinsDictionary.com, http://www.collinsdictionary.com/dictionary/american/relocation
[ix] “Resettlement”, CollinsDictionary.com, http://www.collinsdictionary.com/dictionary/english/resettlement
© 2009-2020 Center for Eurasian Studies (AVİM) All Rights Reserved
No comments yet.
SOME CRITICISMS REGARDING PROF. DR. ERIK-JAN ZÜRCHER’S CENTENNIAL STATEMENT - II
Mehmet Oğuzhan TULUN 14.06.2015
MEDDLING IN TURKISH-ARMENIAN RELATIONS: PROPOSED AMENDMENTS ON THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT RESOLUTION ON 2014 COMMISSION PROGRESS REPORT ON TURKEY
Mehmet Oğuzhan TULUN 03.05.2015
GENOCIDE ACCUSATION AS A FORM OF PUNISHMENT - II
Mehmet Oğuzhan TULUN 04.11.2019
THE 2019 ARMENIAN PATRIARCH OF ISTANBUL ELECTION GUIDELINE AND RELATED DISPUTES
Mehmet Oğuzhan TULUN 21.11.2019
SOME CRITICISMS REGARDING PROF. DR. ERIK-JAN ZÜRCHER’S CENTENNIAL STATEMENT
Mehmet Oğuzhan TULUN 21.04.2015
FROM THE DRAWERS OF ANKARA TO THE DUSTY SHELVES OF ARMENIA: ZURICH PROTOCOLS
Tutku DİLAVER 16.03.2018
EUROPEAN UNION’S DISCRIMINATORY APPROACH TO THE BALKANS AND THE RISE OF SLAV-ORTHODOX DOMINANCE IN THE REGION
Teoman Ertuğrul TULUN 24.04.2017
ITALIAN REACTION TO THE CAROLINGIAN EU PROJECT
Teoman Ertuğrul TULUN 11.04.2019
ARMENIA’S DESPERATE SEARCH FOR FOREIGN INTERVENTION AND ITS HISTORICAL ANTECEDENTS: “THREADS OF CONTINUITY”
THE SPANISH LEGISLATION ON GENOCIDE DENIAL: DEBATES AND THE CURRENT LEGAL SITUATION
Miguel MORENO - Turgut Kerem TUNCEL 04.05.2015
Anastas Mikoyan: Confessions of an Armenian Bolshevik
Sovyet Sonrası Ukrayna’da Devlet, Toplum ve Siyaset - Değişen Dinamikler, Dönüşen Kimlikler
Türk-Ermeni Uyuşmazlığı Üzerine Ömer Engin Lütem Konferansları 2019
Türk-Ermeni Uyuşmazlığı Üzerine Ömer Engin Lütem Konferansları 2018
Ermeni Sorunuyla İlgili İngiliz Belgeleri (1912-1923) - British Documents on Armenian Question (1912-1923)
Turkish-Russian Academics: A Historical Study on the Caucasus
Gürcistan'daki Müslüman Topluluklar: Azınlık Hakları, Kimlik, Siyaset
Armenian Diaspora: Diaspora, State and the Imagination of the Republic of Armenia
Ermeni Sorunu Temel Bilgi ve Belgeler (2. Baskı)